{
  "license": "CC BY 4.0",
  "license_url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",
  "publication": "Memory Hole",
  "publisher": "Hesitation Media",
  "page": "https://hesitation.media/memory-hole/cases/artichoke-bluebird/",
  "note": "Each claim is checked on its own, and its result covers that claim and nothing wider.",
  "reading_labels": {
    "corroborated": "The record shows this",
    "contradicted": "Reported here as refuted",
    "unsubstantiated": "No record of this yet",
    "not assessable on public record": "The public record cannot settle this",
    "evidence gathering": "A document that could test this is not read yet"
  },
  "admiralty": {
    "reliability": {
      "A": "Completely reliable",
      "B": "Usually reliable",
      "C": "Fairly reliable",
      "D": "Not usually reliable",
      "E": "Unreliable",
      "F": "Reliability cannot be judged"
    },
    "credibility": {
      "1": "Confirmed by other sources",
      "2": "Probably true",
      "3": "Possibly true",
      "4": "Doubtful",
      "5": "Improbable",
      "6": "Truth cannot be judged"
    }
  },
  "id": "artichoke-bluebird",
  "ledger_id": "ledger-artichoke-bluebird",
  "shelf": "parapolitics",
  "title": "ARTICHOKE and BLUEBIRD",
  "summary": "The CIA programme approved as BLUEBIRD in 1950 and renamed ARTICHOKE in 1951, and three claims about an involuntary assassin and how long it ran.",
  "upshot": [
    "BLUEBIRD was a CIA programme approved in 1950 and renamed ARTICHOKE in August 1951, according to the Senate committee that examined both in 1976.",
    "A January 1952 ARTICHOKE memo posed the question of an involuntary assassin, according to the assessment behind this topic, and a copy of the memo is not kept on this site yet. There is no record yet that the programme produced one or that it ran into the 1970s: the Senate committee reported in 1976 that the CIA puts the end of ARTICHOKE at 1956, and that some use of its interrogation techniques went on for several years after."
  ],
  "scope_note": "Covers the CIA programmes BLUEBIRD and ARTICHOKE. Project CHATTER, a separate Navy programme, is not included.",
  "status": "claim map published",
  "assessed": "2026-11-19",
  "related": [
    {
      "case": "mkultra",
      "label": "The CIA programme approved in 1953, checked separately"
    }
  ],
  "notices": [],
  "pending": [],
  "subclaims": [
    {
      "id": "c1",
      "text": "A January 1952 memo posed the involuntary-assassin question.",
      "state": "evidence gathering",
      "reading": "A January 1952 ARTICHOKE memo is reported to pose the question, according to the assessment behind this topic. The Senate report pages saved here cite memos of March 22 and Aug. 29, 1952 and a progress report of Jan. 12, 1953, and none of January 1952. The memo itself is not kept on this site yet.",
      "sources": [
        {
          "name": "ARTICHOKE memo",
          "kind": "Memo",
          "date": "January 1952"
        }
      ],
      "reporting_needed": [
        "The January 1952 ARTICHOKE memo, with its page."
      ],
      "reading_label": "A document that could test this is not read yet",
      "page": "https://hesitation.media/memory-hole/cases/artichoke-bluebird/claims/c1/"
    },
    {
      "id": "c2",
      "text": "The programme produced a working involuntary assassin.",
      "grade": "unsubstantiated",
      "reading": "No record read for this topic shows a working involuntary assassin.",
      "sources": [],
      "reporting_needed": [],
      "reading_label": "No record of this yet",
      "page": "https://hesitation.media/memory-hole/cases/artichoke-bluebird/claims/c2/"
    },
    {
      "id": "c3",
      "text": "The programme ran into the 1970s.",
      "grade": "unsubstantiated",
      "reading": "No record read for this topic shows the programme running into the 1970s. The Senate committee reported in 1976 that the CIA puts the end of ARTICHOKE at 1956, and that some use of its interrogation techniques went on for several years after that.",
      "sources": [],
      "reporting_needed": [],
      "reading_label": "No record of this yet",
      "page": "https://hesitation.media/memory-hole/cases/artichoke-bluebird/claims/c3/"
    }
  ],
  "evidence": [
    {
      "id": "e1",
      "title": "Senate committee report on BLUEBIRD and ARTICHOKE, April 26, 1976",
      "type": "Senate Report 94-755, Book I, the final report of the Select Committee to Study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities: title page and pages 385, 387 and 388",
      "source_url": "https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-files-94755-i.pdf",
      "file": "/files/records/ledger-artichoke-bluebird/senate-1976-church-committee-book-1-pages-385-387-388-en.pdf",
      "sha256": "a9823e8baf941853762e40662354234ad4a8a33d62f45d6d23903c83eca20c05",
      "bytes": 218808,
      "excerpt_of": {
        "url": "https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-files-94755-i.pdf",
        "sha256": "2c05ee42c878f95cc921a3c9bbf5cbc4981efd0067747ba896903fa1b1879a68",
        "bytes": 42700052,
        "pages": "1, 385, 387 and 388 of the 642 in the file"
      },
      "provenance": "origin confirmed",
      "custodian": "Senate Select Committee on Intelligence",
      "obtained": {
        "date": "2026-11-20",
        "route": "downloaded from the committee's website, with four pages cut from the file. The file as the site serves it begins with 603 bytes of upload-form text ahead of the PDF, and a PDF reader opens it"
      },
      "establishes": [
        "Project BLUEBIRD \"was approved by the Director in 1950\", and \"In August 1951, the project was renamed ARTICHOKE\" (page 387).",
        "One of its stated objectives was \"investigating the possibility of control of an individual by application of special interrogation techniques\" (page 387).",
        "\"The CIA maintains that the project ended in 1956, but evidence suggests that Office of Security and Office of Medical Services use of 'special interrogation' techniques continued for several years thereafter\" (page 388).",
        "Project CHATTER \"was a Navy program that began in the fall of 1947\" and ended in 1953 (page 387)."
      ],
      "does_not_establish": [
        "Anything about a January 1952 memo. The pages cite memos of March 22 and Aug. 29, 1952, and a progress report of Jan. 12, 1953.",
        "Anything about an assassin. The word does not appear on these pages.",
        "That the programme ran into the 1970s. The latest these pages reach is \"several years\" after 1956.",
        "What happened after the fall of 1953 in any detail. The report calls the information scarce."
      ],
      "attachments": [
        {
          "claim": "c3",
          "direction": "weakens",
          "fidelity": "pending"
        }
      ],
      "described_not_displayed": false,
      "ledger_id": "ledger-artichoke-bluebird",
      "file_url": "https://hesitation.media/files/records/ledger-artichoke-bluebird/senate-1976-church-committee-book-1-pages-385-387-388-en.pdf",
      "page": "https://hesitation.media/memory-hole/cases/artichoke-bluebird/evidence/e1/"
    }
  ],
  "allegations": [],
  "chapters": [],
  "editions": [],
  "single_sources": [],
  "provenance_chain": [],
  "paired_statements": [],
  "outstanding_pulls": [],
  "published_work": [],
  "history": [
    {
      "date": "2026-11-20",
      "kind": "addition",
      "note": "Added four pages of Senate Report 94-755, Book I, downloaded from the Senate intelligence committee's website, as the source for claim 3."
    }
  ]
}