Feb. 12, 1954
Inside the CIA
After Frank Olson's death, the Director of Central Intelligence sent letters criticizing the officers involved.
- How it ended
- A note from the Deputy Director said the letters were not reprimands and that nothing was entered in personnel files. The Senate committee wrote in 1976 that the events had no apparent effect on the officers' advancement.
- Legal ground
- Internal decision
SourcesSenate hearing record, 1977, p. 81 (p. 398 of the 1976 Senate report, reprinted); Senate hearing record, 1977, p. 82 (p. 399 of the 1976 Senate report, reprinted)
1963
Inside the CIA
The Inspector General reported that a final phase of the testing of MKULTRA products put the rights and interests of U.S. citizens in jeopardy; the same report says that phase applied the materials to unwitting subjects in normal life settings. The Senate committee wrote that the covert testing project was terminated in 1963.
- How it ended
- The Senate committee wrote in 1976 that none of the people involved faced disciplinary action.
- Legal ground
- Internal decision
SourcesCIA Inspector General report, 1963, p. 4; CIA Inspector General report, 1963, p. 12; Senate hearing record, 1977, p. 83 (p. 400 of the 1976 Senate report, reprinted); Senate hearing record, 1977, p. 86 (p. 403 of the 1976 Senate report, reprinted)
Sept. 30, 1975
White House and Justice Department
The Olson family's claim was negotiated without a suit. White House files record an Attorney General's offer of $500,000 that the family rejected, and Justice Department support for a private bill of $1,250,000.
- How it ended
- The President approved a private bill of $1,250,000, and it went to Congress as S. 3035. The law Congress passed paid $750,000 (next row).
- Legal ground
- Negotiation
SourcesWhite House files on the Olson claim, p. 7; White House files on the Olson claim, p. 8; White House files on the Olson claim, p. 27; White House files on the Olson claim, p. 28
Oct. 12, 1976
Congress
Private Law 94-126, for the relief of Frank Olson's widow and three children.
- How it ended
- The act paid $187,500 to each of the four, in full settlement of all claims against the United States arising from the death, on condition that all four waive their rights.
- Legal ground
- Legislation, with no court involved
- Paid
- $750,000 in all
SourcePrivate Law 94-126 (1976)
Sept. 1977
Justice Department
The Office of Legal Counsel advised the Criminal Division on whether anyone could be prosecuted.
- How it ended
- The memorandum concluded that convictions would be difficult, if not impossible, without substantial new evidence; that the five-year limitation period appeared to bar prosecution because the activity ceased in 1964; and that the one possibly criminal act was the 1973 destruction of records, which the Director had personally authorized. It recommended a preliminary investigation of the destruction. What that investigation found is not in the files gathered.
- Legal ground
- Limitation period; proof of intent
SourcesJustice Department memorandum, 1977, p. 4; Justice Department memorandum, 1977, p. 1; Justice Department memorandum, 1977, p. 2; Justice Department memorandum, 1977, p. 3
April 16, 1985
U.S. Supreme Court, CIA v. Sims
A Freedom of Information Act suit for the names of the researchers and institutions.
- How it ended
- The Court held that the Director could withhold the researchers' names as intelligence sources, and their institutional affiliations too, because an affiliation could identify a researcher. The CIA had already released the names of 59 institutions that consented.
- Legal ground
- National Security Act section 102(d)(3); FOIA Exemption 3
SourcesCIA v. Sims (1985), p. 15; CIA v. Sims (1985), p. 22; CIA v. Sims (1985), p. 23; CIA v. Sims (1985), p. 5
June 25, 1987
U.S. Supreme Court, United States v. Stanley
Army testing, not MKUltra
A former soldier sued over LSD given to him secretly in an Army test in 1958.
- How it ended
- The Court held that the appeals court had no jurisdiction to revive his tort claim, which the lower courts had held barred by the Feres doctrine, and that he had no damages action against the individuals because the injury arose incident to service. The judgment below was reversed in part, vacated in part and remanded.
- Legal ground
- No jurisdiction over the tort claim on appeal; no Bivens remedy for injuries incident to service
SourcesUnited States v. Stanley (1987), p. 1; United States v. Stanley (1987), p. 4; United States v. Stanley (1987), p. 16; United States v. Stanley (1987), p. 2
Jan. 19, 1988
U.S. District Court, District of Columbia, Orlikow v. United States
Nine former patients of Dr. Ewen Cameron sued over treatment funded under Subproject 68.
- How it ended
- The court refused to end the case for eight plaintiffs and dismissed one as out of time. The case then settled out of court: a Canadian court later recorded that one plaintiff, Jeanine Huard, received US$66,562.50 on Nov. 21, 1988. The total is not in the files gathered. The General Accounting Office told Congress in 1994 of a $750,000 Justice Department settlement with a group of LSD test participants but did not name the suit.
- Legal ground
- Settlement, with no judgment on the merits
- Paid
- Unknown in total; US$66,562.50 to one plaintiff
SourcesOrlikow v. United States (1988); Huard v. Canada (2007), p. 1; Huard v. Canada (2007), p. 20; GAO testimony, 1994, p. 11
Nov. 16, 1992
Government of Canada
An order in council authorized payments to former patients of the Allan Memorial Institute who had been "depatterned".
- How it ended
- The order authorized $100,000 to each person who met its criteria, as an ex gratia payment, and required a signed waiver protecting the Crown and the Royal Victoria Hospital. Some applicants were refused; a court in 2004 held one refused applicant entitled. The files gathered do not show how many people were paid.
- Legal ground
- Ex gratia payment
- Authorized
- $100,000 (Canadian) to each person who met the order's criteria
SourcesHuard v. Canada (2007), p. 24; Huard v. Canada (2007), p. 2; Huard v. Canada (2007), p. 4
July 9, 1998
U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit, Kronisch v. United States
Stanley Glickman alleged he was given an LSD-laced drink in Paris in October 1952. That is before the Director approved MKULTRA on April 13, 1953, so the case concerns CIA LSD testing and is not tied by any page read to a subproject.
- How it ended
- The court held the claim against the United States out of time, and the claims against Gottlieb and Helms for running the programme out of time. It sent one claim back for trial: that Gottlieb personally gave him the drink. The trial's outcome is not in the files gathered.
- Legal ground
- Limitation periods
SourcesKronisch v. United States (1998); Senate hearing record, 1977, p. 73 (p. 390 of the 1976 Senate report, reprinted)
June 26, 2006
U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, Ritchie v. United States
A former deputy marshal alleged that federal agents gave him LSD in 1957. No page read ties the event to a subproject.
- How it ended
- At the close of his case in a bench trial, the district court entered judgment on partial findings that he had not proved federal agents gave him LSD. The appeals court affirmed, while writing that it was quite possible he was drugged.
- Legal ground
- Burden of proof
SourceRitchie v. United States (2006)
Oct. 2, 2023
Court of Appeal of Quebec, Tanny
A proposed class action for people depatterned at the Allan Memorial Institute between 1948 and 1964 named the United States among the defendants.
- How it ended
- The court upheld the dismissal of the claim against the United States on state immunity. The claim against the other proposed defendants was not before it. The copy in the files gathered was taken from the website of the plaintiffs' counsel; a copy from the court's own service is owed.
- Legal ground
- State immunity
SourcesCourt of Appeal of Quebec (2023), p. 1; Court of Appeal of Quebec (2023), p. 2; Court of Appeal of Quebec (2023), p. 3; Court of Appeal of Quebec (2023), p. 4; Court of Appeal of Quebec (2023), p. 5; Court of Appeal of Quebec (2023), p. 21