Saturday, November 21, 2026Pittsburgh · Newsletter
Hesitation Media

Enterprise investigative reporting and forecasting for people keeping up with current events.

Memory HoleHesitation Media · slow journalism

Rules on experiments with human subjects since MKUltra

The rule that binds U.S. intelligence agencies today is section 2.10 of Executive Order 12333.

Below are 9 rules in date order, each read from its own text: what it says, whom it binds and what it says about intelligence agencies. The statutes among them are addressed to the Defense Department and to health-department programmes.

Rules

Oct. 26, 1972

Department of Defense Appropriation Act, 1973, Public Law 92-570, section 745

Whom it binds
Funds appropriated by that Act for the Department of Defense, fiscal year ending June 30, 1973
What it says
None of the funds appropriated by the Act shall be available for any research involving uninformed or nonvoluntary human beings as experimental subjects.
On intelligence agencies
The section names no agency. The same Act appropriated $450,187,000 for intelligence and communication activities of Defense agencies (86 Stat. 1188), so the bar reached those funds; nothing in the files gathered shows that any of the Act's funds went to the CIA. The notes to 10 U.S.C. 980 list this Act as the first of the appropriation acts with similar provisions.

SourcesPublic Law 92-570 (1972), p. 20; Public Law 92-570 (1972), p. 5; 10 U.S.C. 980

July 12, 1974

National Research Act, Public Law 93-348

Whom it binds
Research under Department of Health, Education, and Welfare programmes (the Act amends the Public Health Service Act)
What it says
Establishes the National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research.
On intelligence agencies
The text of the Act contains no occurrence of CIA, Central Intelligence, intelligence or classified.

SourcesNational Research Act (1974), p. 1; National Research Act (1974), p. 7

Feb. 18, 1976

Executive Order 11905, section 5(d), "Restrictions on Experimentation"

Whom it binds
Foreign intelligence agencies
What it says
Bars them from experimenting with drugs on human subjects unless each subject consents in writing, witnessed by a disinterested third party.
On intelligence agencies
This is the earliest clause in the files gathered addressed to intelligence agencies. An earlier statute restricting experimentation on human subjects is now in the files gathered: section 745 of the Defense appropriation act of Oct. 26, 1972 (86 Stat. 1203) barred that Act's funds, which included $450,187,000 for Defense intelligence and communication activities, from research on uninformed or nonvoluntary human subjects; the files gathered does not show whether that bar, or any earlier order or statute, reached the CIA.

SourcesExecutive Order 11905 (1976); 10 U.S.C. 980; Public Law 92-570 (1972), p. 20; Public Law 92-570 (1972), p. 5

Jan. 24, 1978

Executive Order 12036, section 2-302, "Restrictions on Experimentation"

Whom it binds
The intelligence community
What it says
Supersedes the 1976 order. The clause no longer speaks only of drugs: it covers research on human subjects, under health-department guidelines.
On intelligence agencies
Read from a copy held by the Federation of American Scientists. The Federal Register text (43 FR 3674) is not in the files gathered.

SourceExecutive Order 12036 (1978)

April 18, 1979

The Belmont Report

Whom it binds
Guidance, written by the National Commission
What it says
States the basic ethical principles for research on human subjects.
On intelligence agencies
The report contains no occurrence of CIA, Central Intelligence or classified.

SourceBelmont Report (1979)

Dec. 4, 1981

Executive Order 12333, section 2.10, "Human Experimentation"

Whom it binds
Every agency in the Intelligence Community
What it says
No agency may sponsor, contract for or conduct research on human subjects except under guidelines issued by the Department of Health and Human Services, and the subject's informed consent must be documented as those guidelines require.
On intelligence agencies
This is the clause in force. The 2017 Common Rule says the CIA follows the health-department regulations by virtue of this order.

SourcesExecutive Order 12333 (1981); Common Rule, 2017 final rule

1984 and 1997

10 U.S.C. 980 and 50 U.S.C. 1520a

Whom it binds
The Secretary of Defense and Defense Department funds
What it says
Limit the use of people as experimental subjects and bar listed tests of chemical or biological agents without informed consent. The notes to 10 U.S.C. 980 say similar provisions were carried in Defense appropriation acts from Oct. 26, 1972.
On intelligence agencies
Both are addressed to the Defense Department.

Sources50 U.S.C. 1520a; 10 U.S.C. 980

March 27, 1997

Presidential memorandum, "Strengthened Protections for Human Subjects of Classified Research"

Whom it binds
Nineteen officials, among them the Director of Central Intelligence
What it says
Orders the agencies to propose changes to the Common Rule for classified research: informed consent may not be waived, expedited review is barred, and subjects must be told the sponsoring agency except in studies of minimal risk. Final rules were to be issued within one year. No classified project on human subjects may go ahead unless the head of the agency has personally approved it.
On intelligence agencies
Read from a copy held by the Federation of American Scientists. The 2017 final rule cites the memorandum at 62 FR 26367, which shows it exists; the Federal Register text is not in the files gathered.

SourcesPresidential memorandum (1997); Common Rule, 2017 final rule

Jan. 19, 2017

Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects, final rule, 82 FR 7149 (the revised Common Rule)

Whom it binds
Sixteen departments and agencies; the CIA is not among them
What it says
The word "classified" appears nine times, all in the preamble and none in the regulatory text, and the rule has no section on classified research. Commenters asked that waivers of consent be barred for classified research. The regulatory text excludes from "research" authorized operational activities in support of intelligence, as each agency determines.
On intelligence agencies
The preamble says the CIA will continue to follow the health-department regulations under the executive order, and that the rule does not supersede the order.

SourceCommon Rule, 2017 final rule

Documents still sought

  • Any rule in force before 1976 that bound the CIA on experiments with human subjects.
  • Any CIA or Director of National Intelligence regulation on human-subject research. None was found public.
  • Defense Department Instruction 3216.02 (the fetch failed).
  • Any proposed or final rule that carried out the 1997 memorandum. The 1998 notice in the files gathered concerns another subject and does not contain the word "classified".
  • The Federal Register text of Executive Order 12036 (43 FR 3674) and of the 1997 memorandum (62 FR 26367). The order was read in copies held by the Federation of American Scientists and the American Presidency Project, and the memorandum in the Federation's copy.
  • The later Defense appropriation acts, to 1984, that the notes to 10 U.S.C. 980 list. The first of them, of Oct. 26, 1972, has been read.
  • Three older instruments that files in the case name and none of which has been read: a 1953 Secretary of Defense memorandum on the consent of volunteers, Army Regulation 70-25, and the 1971 guidelines of the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.

Second check done.

Every document cited is on the Documents page. Download this investigation as data (JSON, CC BY 4.0). How it was done: method. Report an error: corrections.